Fostering Genuine Friendships Part 2: A Guide on Managing Anxious and Avoidant Attachment
In Part 1, we explored how making and maintaining friendships as an adult starts with you—your self-awareness, your attachment patterns, and the skills you may (or may not) have learned growing up.
We talked about how growing up with overly critical or emotionally immature parents can stunt our emotional growth, leaving us without the tools we need to form healthy, lasting friendships. We also looked at how you can start building those skills now—by managing negative thoughts, working through insecure attachments (anxious, avoidant, or disorganized), and reflecting on the kind of friendships you want to create.
Today, let’s go deeper. We’ll focus on practical ways to manage negative thoughts and regulate yourself when your insecure attachment is triggered—whether that’s anxious, avoidant, or a mix of both.
Step One: Know When You’re in Trauma Mode vs. Your True Self
One of the most important skills for building healthy friendships is being able to recognize when you’re operating from an old wound rather than your grounded, authentic self.
The best way to build this awareness is by working with a therapist who can guide you through it, but if you’re not sure therapy is for you yet, you can start with some honest self-reflection.
Ask yourself:
- How did I learn to resolve conflicts growing up?
- Was I allowed to express myself as a child? (For example: choosing foods I liked, wearing clothes I felt good in, picking sports or activities I enjoyed.)
- Were my accomplishments praised? Was I supported—or punished—when I didn’t do well?
- Did I have to hide my feelings and prioritize my parents’ emotions over my own?
- Could I go to my parents when I was upset and trust they would support me?
- Did they show a genuine interest in my life, asking about my day, my friends, my feelings?
Your answers will give you clues about how navigating relationships was modeled for you, because kids are little sponges absorbing their environment and learning by observing.
If you grew up with parents who relied on you to manage their emotions (not a child’s job, by the way), you may have developed codependency or anxious attachment.
If your parents showed little interest or did the bare minimum, you may have learned you can’t rely on others, leading to avoidant behaviors.
Understanding this is key. It’s not about blaming the past—it’s about knowing when old patterns are steering the ship so you can choose a different direction.
How to Tell if Your Anxious Attachment Is Being Triggered in a Friendship (or Relationship)
Anxious attachment often grows from early experiences where emotional needs weren’t met consistently. When care felt close one moment and distant the next, a child can learn to scan for signs of rejection or abandonment. This might have looked like being comforted sometimes but not others, being told to handle big feelings alone, spending long stretches with relatives, being left to entertain yourself, or having your interests dismissed. Then, at other times, your caregiver was attentive and present—leaving you anxious and unsure about when attention or support would arrive.
When this pattern is triggered in friendships, you may notice certain thoughts, feelings, or behaviors show up, sometimes so automatically that you don’t realize they’re tied to your attachment system. By “triggered,” I mean a friend might do or say something small that echoes the way you were treated growing up. Your nervous system recognizes the trigger before your mind does. This isn’t a flaw; it’s an old protection strategy trying to keep you safe.
With gentle curiosity, you can start to pause and ask: What is coming up for me right now? What does this remind me of? That awareness is a powerful first step toward soothing the anxious part of you and choosing a steadier, more grounded response.
Let’s explore this further.
1. Heightened Sensitivity to Changes in Communication
- If your friend takes longer than usual to reply to a message, you might instantly wonder:
- Did I do something wrong?
- Are they upset with me?
- Small shifts in tone or frequency of contact can feel bigger than they are, prompting worry or rumination.
2. Overthinking Interactions
- Replaying a conversation in your head to check if you said something “weird” or “too much.”
- Analyzing their words, emojis, or social media activity for hidden meaning.
- Seeking reassurance—either directly (“Are we okay?”) or indirectly (dropping hints).
3. Emotional Spikes
- A sudden wave of anxiety, tightness in your chest, or an unsettled feeling when you sense distance.
- A mix of relief and euphoria when your friend responds warmly after you’ve been worried.
4. Fear of Being “Too Much”
- Worrying that your emotional needs will push people away.
- Holding back from expressing feelings until they spill out in an intense burst.
5. People-Pleasing to Maintain Connection
- Saying “yes” to plans you don’t have the energy for.
- Agreeing with things you don’t actually agree with, just to avoid conflict.
How to Self-Regulate When Your Anxious Attachment Is Triggered
When your anxious attachment is activated, your nervous system is in “threat mode,” scanning for signs of rejection or abandonment. In this state, it’s easy to spiral into overthinking or reach for quick reassurance.
Instead of letting the trigger run the show, you can practice slowing down and calming your body first, so your next steps come from a grounded place.
1. Set realistic goals and track your progress.
- Simply saying to yourself, “This is my anxious attachment being activated,” helps you create distance from the feeling.
- Naming it reduces shame—it’s not that you’re “too much,” it’s that your attachment system is looking for safety.
2. Regulate Your Nervous System
- Deep, slow breathing — Inhale for a count of 4, hold for 4, exhale for 4. I also really love “Breathe with Sandy” on YouTube; he’s great for releasing stress in the body. If you can practice it in a calming environment, even better.
- Gentle movement — A walk, stretching, or yoga can help release the physical tension anxiety creates.
- Distractions — If you’ve tried breathwork and gentle movement and you’re still feeling anxious, it is perfectly okay to schedule some distractions with family, friends, or yourself. This can look like going to the movies, museums, a spa, or having a picnic at the park. Check in with your younger self and ask them what would make them feel better.
3. Reality-Check Your Thoughts
Ask yourself:
- What evidence do I have that my friend is upset with me?
- What are other possible explanations for their behavior?
Remind yourself: “The story my mind is telling isn’t always the truth.”
4. Meet the Need Yourself First
Before reaching out for reassurance, try:
- Write yourself a compassionate note.
- Listening to a song that makes you feel loved.
- Recalling a time your friend did show up for you to balance the mental narrative.
5. Communicate from a Calm Place
If you still feel unsettled, you can express your needs clearly and gently:
- “Hey, I noticed I haven’t heard from you in a bit, and I miss talking. Is everything okay?”
- Coming from calm curiosity instead of fear often leads to more connection.
Remember:
Self-regulation doesn’t mean you stop having needs—it means you give yourself the safety you’re craving in the moment, so you can approach your friendships with more clarity and trust.
Why This Matters:
When you can name these signs as “my anxious attachment being activated,” you create a little bit of space between the feeling and the story your mind is telling. That space allows you to respond with self-compassion instead of acting from fear.
How to Tell if Your Avoidant Attachment Is Being Triggered in a Friendship
Avoidant attachment often develops from early experiences where emotional closeness felt unsafe, overwhelming, or met with rejection. As a result, sharing your feelings may feel risky, and independence can feel like the safest place to be.
When your avoidant attachment is triggered in a friendship, you might notice yourself creating distance, sometimes without even realizing it. Let’s explore this further.
1. Feeling the Urge to Pull Away
- You suddenly feel less interested in making plans or replying to messages.
- You tell yourself you just “need space,” but it’s more about avoiding discomfort than true rest.
2. Downplaying Emotional Needs
- You convince yourself you don’t really need support, even when you’re struggling.
- You minimize how much a friend means to you to avoid feeling dependent.
3. Becoming Hyper-Focused on Flaws
- You start zeroing in on little things that bother you about your friend (their habits, tone, or choices).
- These irritations can become a subconscious way of justifying emotional distance.
4. Shutting Down When Things Get Emotional
- Deep conversations or emotional vulnerability can feel overwhelming, leading you to change the subject, joke, or withdraw.
- You may notice physical signs of discomfort—tightness in your shoulders, a quickened heart rate—when a friend gets too close emotionally.
5. Prioritizing Independence Over Connection
- You take pride in “not needing anyone,” but this can sometimes be a defense against being hurt.
- You prefer to solve problems alone rather than risk feeling let down by others.
Why This Matters:
Noticing when your avoidant attachment is activated can help you pause before creating unnecessary distance. With awareness, you can practice leaning in, just a little, when your instinct is to shut the door. Small moments of openness can build the trust and safety needed for genuine friendships.
How to Self-Regulate When Your Avoidant Attachment Is Triggered
When your avoidant attachment is activated, your nervous system shifts into “self-protection mode.” Closeness may suddenly feel overwhelming, and your instinct is to pull away to regain a sense of control. While taking space can sometimes be healthy, withdrawing too much can unintentionally harm a friendship.
Learning to regulate first gives you more choice in how you respond.
1. Pause and Acknowledge the Trigger
- Silently name it: “This is my avoidant attachment being activated.”
- Recognizing the pattern helps you see that the urge to pull away may be about old wounds, not necessarily the present moment.
2. Regulate Your Body Before Retreating
- Ground your senses — Notice the feel of your feet on the floor or the texture of the chair beneath you.
- Progressive muscle relaxation — Gently tense and release each muscle group from head to toe.
- Slow exhales — Extending your out-breath signals safety to your nervous system. As reviewed with anxious attachment, utilizing free resources like “Breathe with Sandy” on YouTube can help you connect with your emotions and breathe through them.
3. Get Curious About the Discomfort
Ask yourself:
- What am I afraid will happen if I stay emotionally present?
- Is there a specific moment that triggered this need to pull away? Did that moment remind you of something deeper?
Avoidant triggers are often about feeling exposed, controlled, or vulnerable—naming this helps you respond more intentionally.
4. Allow Space Without Total Disconnection
Instead of cutting off contact, try a balanced approach:
- Let your friend know you need a little downtime and when you’ll reconnect.
- Use the space for true self-care (rest, hobbies) rather than ruminating on their flaws.
- For romantic relationships, a good rule of thumb is that taking space for yourself shouldn’t be more than 24 hours for mild-moderate disagreements.
5. Re-Engage in Small, Low-Pressure Ways
- Send a short check-in text or a funny meme.
- Share something light before returning to a deeper conversation.
- Lean into gradual reconnection—it helps your nervous system see that closeness can feel safe.
Remember:
Self-regulation doesn’t mean forcing yourself to open up before you’re ready. It’s about slowing down your protective reflexes just enough to keep the door to connection open. Despite what your body might be telling you, we are wired for human connection and can thrive in healthy relationships.
Final Thoughts
Whether your attachment style leans anxious, avoidant, or disorganized, the key is building self-awareness and practicing regulation before reacting. The more you can notice your patterns, the more choice you have in how you show up in your friendships.
If you’ve been feeling stuck in cycles of overthinking, withdrawal, or self-doubt in your relationships, you don’t have to figure it out alone. Therapy can help you untangle old patterns, heal past wounds, and learn the skills to create friendships that feel safe, supportive, and lasting.
🌅 I offer free consultations so you can explore what this support might look like—no pressure, just a conversation about where you are and where you want to go.
Explore more insights
